top of page

Meet our teachers 

Meet Our Staff

Called to equip God's people for God's work in the world. 



Caroline Cupp

Executive Pastor

Caroline came to First Presbyterian Church in 2015 after serving as a professional hospital chaplain and clinical pastoral education supervisor. Her responsibilities at First Pres center on supporting the deacons and caregiving ministries of the church as well as working with the congregation around mission and outreach both locally and abroad. She is a graduate of Yale Divinity School (Master of Divinity), the and the University of Pennsylvania (Master of Bioethics). Caroline and husband Kevin were both born and raised in Chester County. Kevin is a graduate of Messiah College (’02) and works in the information security field.

Tara headshot mono.jpg

Tara Woodard-Lehman 

Bridge Pastor


Tara Woodard-Lehman is a writer, teacher, artist, and ordained Presbyterian Church (USA) minister. Since 1998 she has served in a variety of ministry settings as a Lilly Fellow, University Chaplain, Lecturer, and Parish Associate. A member at large in the Pittsburgh Presbytery, Tara serves in a variety of local congregations as a pulpit supply preacher and has ministered with several congregations in the midst of transition. She brings a unique diversity and depth to her pastoral experience, having served both here in the United States and abroad in New Zealand. Tara enjoys restoring furniture, exploring nature, and tending to her high-energy beagle, Hook. She is married to Dr. Derek Woodard-Lehman, a Lecturer in Theology and Ethics at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary. Together they are raising two boys, Josiah and Eli.

Ann CROP.jpg

Ann Dickey

Parish Associate

Ann began serving at First Pres in September of 2019. Since moving here in 1984, Ann Garrou Dickey has pastored four churches in Chester County: Westminster West Chester, Unionville, Doe Run, and Bethany Mendenhall and two in North Carolina in her 38 years of ministry. She is married to David Dickey and has two married children, Heather and James and three very special grandchildren. She retired in 2018 and loves being part of the FPC family!

Anderson Crop 02.jpg

Anderson Porter 

Parish Associate

Anderson began serving First Presbyterian Church in 1997. Born in Bristol, Virginia in 1930, Anderson graduated from Lincoln University with a BA and and M. Div. He was the chair of the local NAACP during the 1960's and even coordinated buses of people from Chester County to attend the March on Washington in 1963. He has pastored numerous churches including Second United Presbyterian in West Chester, and both Bethel Presbyterian and Reeve Memorial Presbyterian in Philadelphia. Anderson has served as both Parish Associate to First Pres and Supply Pastor to Wissinoming Presbyterian since 1997. 



Sándor Kádár

Director of Music

Sándor has been serving First Presbyterian Church since May 2016. He holds three bachelor’s degrees in Organ Performance, Sacred Music, and Choral Conducting, as well as a master’s degree in Sacred Music from the University of Music and Performing Arts in Graz (Austria). He came to the US in 2012 as a scholarship recipient of prestigious Westminster Choir College in Princeton, NJ. At the age of 12, Sándor already knew that his calling was to become an organist. He also believes that music has the power of bringing people closer to God. In his free time, Sándor enjoys having good conversations with his friends and walking in nature, especially in spring and fall. He does not have a TV but his loss is compensated by a 1300 cc Yamaha V Star.

Sara P.jpg

Sara Pantazes

Director of Faith Formation

Sara joined the children's ministry team at First Presbyterian in the summer of 2016. She is passionate about finding creative ways to help all of God's children know and experience God and develop faith as they grow. She holds a Master of Arts in Christian Education from Union Presbyterian Seminary and a B.A. from the College of William and Mary. Sara lives in West Grove with her husband and two sons. She enjoys reading, cooking, and exercising, and treasures time with family and friends.

Elizabeth CROP 02.jpg

Elizabeth Hess

Director of Engagement

Elizabeth has been on the First Pres staff two previous times and is back as the Director of Engagement. She will be overseeing visitor outreach, hospitality, and helping members use their gifts in meaningful ways. She loves the First Pres family and considers it a privilege to serve. She has lived in West Chester her entire life and loves it! She and her husband have two daughters and her favorite dog of all time: Teddy, a goldendoodle. In her spare time, Elizabeth loves to read and bake.

teager headshot.jpg

David Teager

Office Administrator 

David is new to First Pres but not new to being a Presbyterian, having been baptized as an infant and a long-time member of First & Central in Wilmington, Delaware, where he serves as an Elder and sings in the Chancel Choir. A chemist by training, he answered God’s call by serving a decade researching ways to improve manufacturing of HIV medications for use in the developing world. Already a seasoned traveler, this work took him to India, Brazil, China, and Africa. He is grateful to answer this new call to serve First Presbyterian, and hopes to resume pleasure travel with his husband, Stephen.

Jeff CROP.jpg

Jeff Somers

Director of Finance and Operations

Jeff began working at First Presbyterian in February of 2019. He is originally from Stroudsburg, PA and graduated from Bloomsburg University. He also earned an MBA from Villanova University. For the past 18+ years he was employed by USA Today and its parent company, the Gannett Company. He was most recently the National Director of Business Operations, spending seven years in Charlotte, NC. While previously residing in the Lansdale, PA area, Jeff served on the church council as well as the stewardship committee for many years at a large Lutheran church. Jeff now resides in Wilmington, DE with his wife Lisa, who is a fourth-grade teacher at the Tower Hill School. They have two adult children, Kyle and Krista, and two grandchildren. Being animal lovers, they also have several dogs and cats that all live harmoniously! Lisa and Jeff enjoy walking the dogs and spending time in Cape May Point. Jeff is a fan of all Philly sports teams and of course Villanova basketball. He enjoys watching sports in person and on television as well as working on home improvement projects.

Jen R - CROP.jpg

Jennifer Rosenberg

Preschool Director

Jen is entering her eighth year at the Bucket School.  She previously taught in both the 2s and 3s Bucket School classes.  She has a BS in Elementary Education with a minor in Early Childhood Education from Marywood University, Scranton, PA. She resides in the Borough of West Chester with her husband, Eric and their two boys, Jack and Henry, who are both alumni of the Bucket School. Teaching young children is her passion and she loves to watch them grow throughout the years at the school.  She is very excited to be in her new role and will continue to love and educate the children here at The Bucket School.

Karen CROP.jpg

Karen Goldstein

Office Manager

Karen began working at First Pres as a part-time secretary while her three children were in early elementary school. That was back in September of 1987 – she has been here over 35 years and has been the Office Manager since 1999. She and her husband Dave live in Coatesville, where he is enjoying retirement from teaching and coaching college football. They have 4 grandchildren. In her free time, Karen enjoys gourmet cooking, reading, as well as traveling with her husband all over the world – their favorite was going to South Africa which included safaris in Zimbabwe and Botswana.  It was an amazing experience.

Willy CROP 02.jpg

Willy Oliveras


Willy joined the First Pres Staff as a Full Time Custodian in January, 2006.  Prior to that, he worked for Wyeth Labs in the same field for many years.  Born in Puerto Rico, he moved to Florida at 17, and on to West Chester, PA at the age of 18.  Willy feels comfortable enough with the church that he calls First Pres, “home” and misses it when he is away. Willy always tries to catch one service each Sunday – his favorite part is the music and he enjoys both traditional hymns and our new contemporary music style. About 7 years ago, His companion Estella came from Puerto Rico to West Chester for the first time. In their spare time, they love to watch movies at home and go shopping. Shopping trips often include one of their 16 grandchildren – they have 8 each!

Marci Major_edited.jpg

Marci Major

Children's Choir Director

Marci began serving at First Pres in September 2021. She is Chair and Associate Professor of Music Education and Music Therapy at West Chester University of Pennsylvania and directs the Bel Canto ensemble with the Kennett Symphony Children’s Chorus. She earned her B.S. in Music Education from West Chester University, her M.M. in Choral Conducting from Michigan State University, and her Ph.D. in Music Education from The Ohio State University. Prior to her appointment at WCU, Marci taught middle and high school choir in Michigan, served at several churches as a choir director or music director, and was Assistant Professor of Music Education and Assistant Director of Choral Activities at the University of Missouri. She resides in West Chester, with her husband Daniel, son Clayton, and daughter Josie.

Kiana R.jpg

Kiana Rivera

Lead Singer, Contemporary Band

Kiana has been worshipping with First Presbyterian Church since the Fall of 2019. Originally from the Lehigh Valley, Kiana moved to Chester County to complete her bachelor’s degree in Music Education at West Chester University. During her final year, she joined our choral scholar program in the 9:00 traditional service, singing with the Chancel Choir and playing in the JuBellation handbell choir. In January of 2020, she joined our Contemporary service as a vocalist. Kiana has been a part of worship groups for as long as she can remember. She is passionate about singing. When she was a child, a pastor gave a word over her life: that she would be a worshiper for God’s kingdom. She enjoyed volunteering with the church when the ESL program first began and serves as a leader in First Pres’ youth ministry program. Kiana also loves reading and going on new adventures with her boyfriend, Kevin. She is currently enrolled in a Post-Baccalaureate Spanish Teaching Certification program at WCU and is expected to graduate in the Spring 2023.

Peyton headshot (1).jpg

Peyton Cole

Assistant Organist

Peyton is a senior at West Chester University currently pursuing a B.A. in Music Composition and Piano and a Minor in Organ Performance. He also teaches piano at the West Chester Music Academy. Besides music, Peyton has taught kids for almost a decade in a variety of subjects ranging from karate, math, camping and outdoorsmanship. Outside of work, studies, and practicing, you can find him out on the trails hiking with friends, fishing, or at home binging a good Netflix series. He is a proud eagle scout. 

Gretchen CROP 02.jpg

Gretchen Huebner

Wedding & Funeral Coordinator

Wedding Coordinator is her job function at present but she has also served as a bookkeeper, teacher and Assistant Director of the Bucket School in years past. Gretchen graduated from Kutztown State College with a degree in Elementary Education and is certified in Bookkeeping. She has used these skills at First Pres for over 20 years.  She has a passion for helping others and works tirelessly in the areas of ending hunger, providing meals for those in need, volunteering for Meals on Wheels, and making hats for Naphtali and Migrant Ministry.  She also fundraises for these passions using her organizational, leadership and cooking skills in running bake sales, Stop Hunger Now events, Bridge Dinners, the National Day of Prayer. She has been married to Glenn for 35 years they have two children whom both live in West Chester. They are blessed to be so close and enjoy volunteering as a family for different events. She has a broad range of skills and passions that she uses throughout her ministry here at First Pres.


Nolan Prochnau

Technical Support Coordinator

As an Exton native, Nolan has grown up in the church, participating in the services as a musician for years. He has been a part of the Children’s Choir, the Youth Choir, and the JuBellation handbell choir, as well as participating as an instrumental soloist. When the 10:42 contemporary service started in 2018, Nolan started volunteering in the back of the sanctuary, helping to run the tech equipment. He is a current student at West Chester University, pursuing a degree in Viola Performance.

bottom of page